Marillion-Seasons End (1989)

Fish vs. Hogarth: this is undoubtedly one of the biggest catalysts for any discussion among Marillion fans, to the point that some online forums about the band categorically forbid even mentioning a comparison between these two singers, for fear of an electronic war that will clog up servers and computers. Beyond this exaggerated claim, it's relevant to the departure of the towering Fish and the arrival of Steve Hogarth as his replacement, and what Hogarth brought to Marillion, which was immense (and still is). Although the band's purists blame Hogarth for the group's musical shift towards a more pop-oriented sound, at the expense of the progressive grandeur of their early albums, the truth is that if there's one thing both sides agree on, it's his powerful voice, with its excellent range, and his talent as a great lyricist who invites reflection. All of this is clearly demonstrated on much of Marillion's first album after Fish and their first with Hogarth in the band, "Seasons End" from 1989. This was the first real testament to what the singer accomplished with Marillion as a band, and having said all that, "Seasons End" sounds brilliant and is undoubtedly an excellent and worthy successor to the superb album that preceded it with Fish in the lineup, "Clutching At Straws", released several years earlier. Right from its opening track, the incredible "King Of Sunset Town", it demonstrates the peak at which Marillion burst onto the scene and rise triumphantly, ready to begin another chapter, thus dispelling the doubts of those who predicted their downfall and eventual demise. The beautiful "Easter" is the singer's first major contribution to the group's repertoire, a track featuring one of Steve Rothery's best solos of his entire career and a rhythm as captivating as it is brilliant. The slow and mysterious “Seasons End” concludes with an epic and hypnotic finale that showcases the band's instrumental prowess. In “The Uninvited Guest”, we can already sense the direction of their new venture, a track that leans towards rock and commercial sounds with powerful guitar and bass lines. The melodic and heartfelt “Holloway Girl” is one of the album's lesser moments, while the nostalgic “Berlin” is a palpable demonstration of Hogarth's vocal excellence, a song as melancholic as it is dark, which, as it progresses, transforms into a powerful track with a stunning ending. After the short, acoustic “After Me”, comes the powerful, commercially oriented rock track “Hooks In You”, before concluding with the exquisite and progressive “The Space”, one of the album's most memorable moments and a fitting finale to Steve Hogarth's first major contribution to the Marillion universe.